Monday September 21, 2020

Budget 2019 won’t be causing any street protests

In terms of its vote-getting ability, the tax cuts are relatively modest and unlikely to sway the electorate one way or another

Michael Brennan

Political Editor

9th October, 2018
Will Budget 2019 be this government's last? Pic: Getty

Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe said that his second full budget was responsible and had left the country ‘Brexit-ready’. But did it leave his party ‘election-ready'?

There is a case for the prosecution and the defence. On the prosecution side, Donohoe increased the housing budget by almost €500 million in an attempt to deal with a housing crisis that threatens his party’s re-election prospects. He did the same with health, where the budget is going up by €1.2 billion, although there is no guarantee that the trolley crisis and the long waiting lists will vanish anytime soon.

The overall increases in public spending of 4 per cent has paid for other vote-winning measures such as a €5 increase in the state pension and in welfare payments. There was a €29 million allocation to pay for the start of ‘pay equalisation’ for public sector workers. There are going to be another 800 gardaí, 950 extra special needs assistants and 1,300 new teachers. There is a strong case for all of them – but creating extra public sector jobs always helps to generate some extra votes too.

whatever this budget was, it wasn’t a green budget

Donohoe avoided increasing carbon tax or excise on diesel, which would have been an unpopular move with commuters driving long distances to work. That prompted the normally mild-mannered Green Party leader Eamon Ryan to say: “Shame on you”. Donohoe had promised that we will see more of the government’s intent in the ten-year national development plan. And he is going to set out a plan to increase the carbon tax to reduce carbon emissions. But whatever this budget was, it wasn’t a green budget.

In terms of its vote-getting ability, the tax cuts are relatively modest and unlikely to sway the electorate one way or another. But this has been the final budget of the three-year confidence and supply agreement between Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil. If no extension is negotiated in the coming months, then Donohoe has given his party a budget which has a little for everyone – and very few measures that will generate any street protests.

Related Stories

Large public capital projects could be run through an “independent panel of international experts” as part of public spending reforms, according to the Department of Public Expenditure

Daniel Murray | 10 months ago

The contract covers the supply of office stationery to a range of government bodies and agencies, including the HSE, universities, hospitals, councils and schools

Michael Brennan | 10 months ago

Party would launch the ‘largest public house building programme that Ireland has ever seen’ and a national health service

Aiden Corkery | 10 months ago