Sentencing policy back in the spotlight

Calls for mandatory sentences fail to take into account individual circumstances of defendants, writes Kieron Wood.

27th January, 2013
Mr Justice Paul Carney: the O'Brien case has led to calls for mandatory sentences for rape. Photo: Courtpix

Mr Justice Paul Carney's effective three-year prison sentence for a father who raped his daughter resulted in a chorus of calls for mandatory sentencing, Oireachtas intervention and the judge's resignation.

Carney last week sentenced 72-year-old Patrick O'Brien, of Bray, Co Wicklow, to 12 years' imprisonment with nine years suspended for raping and sexually assaulting his daughter, Fiona Doyle.

O'Brien was bailed pending an appeal, but the bail was rescinded last Thursday, and the judge expressed "profound...

Subscribe from just €1 for the first month!

Exclusive offers:

All Digital Access + eReader



Unlimited Access for 1 Month

Get basic

*New subscribers only

You can cancel any time.



€149 For the 1st Year

Unlimited Access for 1 Year

You can cancel any time.




90 Day Pass

You can cancel any time.

2 Yearly



Unlimited Access for 2 Years

You can cancel any time.

Team Pass

Get a Business Account for you and your team

Share this post

Related Stories

The year in review

Legacy Richie Oakley 1 year ago

Newsround: What Thursday’s papers say

Legacy Leanna Byrne 5 years ago

More cycle routes, expansion of Luas to Bray and new bus network proposed

Legacy Digital Desk 5 years ago