Comment: Harris must show backbone on Portlaoise hospital

Is it a case of one rule for John Halligan and another for Charlie Flanagan, asks Susan Mitchell

Susan Mitchell

Deputy Editor and Health Editor @susmitchellsbp
7th October, 2016
Simon Harris stressed he will be guided by expert opinion. Pic:

When the spat erupted over cardiac services at University Hospital Waterford, Minister for Health Simon Harris stressed he would be guided by expert clinical opinion.

The government had commissioned a review from an independent expert Dr Niall Herity, who recommended against a second cath lab in Waterford.

Consultants working in Waterford and the clinical director of the hospital group in the south have said this is the wrong call.

Harris said he would be “guided by independent clinical advice”.

He has stood over the Herity report and its recommendations despite coming under huge pressure from his Cabinet colleague John Halligan.

Halligan is a Waterford TD and member of the Independent Alliance.

Halligan threatened to pull his support from the government, but the government held firm.

It will be interesting to see what Harris will do with proposals that concern the home turf of his Fine Gael party colleague, Minister for Foreign Affairs Charlie Flanagan.

In June, the Dublin Midlands Hospital Group submitted a plan to the Department of Health that proposed replacing the emergency department at Portlaoise Hospital with a minor injuries unit.

The plan for the hospital also proposed removing maternity care and paediatric services from Portlaoise Hospital.

Senior clinicians at the hospital group – which includes hospitals in Tallaght, Tullamore, Naas as well as St James’s Hospital in Dublin – believe this is the right move.

They believe it will ensure patients are given better care in the right facility.

National clinical leads across the health service support this plan.

Little or nothing has been said on an official level since it was submitted. This is ominous.

Will it be a case of one rule for Halligan and a different one for Flanagan?

Hiqa (Health Information and Quality Authority) published a major investigation into Portlaoise last year following the deaths of a number of babies at the hospital.

Hiqa’s comprehensive review highlighted the low volumes of complex patients as a key concern.

Specialist doctors need to see a certain volume of patients, or carry out a certain number of procedures, in order to maintain their skills.

Hiqa’s report was highly critical of the failure to resource the level of services provided in the hospital, including its 24-hour emergency care.

Emergency department staff need to be able to access specialists in relevant specialities, including critical care, coronary care, as well as trauma and orthopaedic care to provide optimum treatment.

This is not available at Portlaoise.

Portlaoise Hospital was one of ten hospitals chosen by the HSE to have their 24/7 emergency departments downgraded in 2011.

Health sources said there was significant political interference by the last government, with the HSE forced to remove the hospital from the list.

And yet, here we are in 2016 and the hospital is still trying to provide a 24/7 emergency department.

Politicians are reacting as follows.

Local TD and Minister for Foreign Affairs Charlie Flanagan said he would not support the proposed plans.

Fianna Fail TD for Laois Sean Fleming said that Fianna Fail would not support it.

RTE broadcaster Sean O’Rourke interviewed Fine Gael TD John Deasy on Wednesday. Waterford is Deasy’s constituency.

O’Rourke asked Deasy whether he supported the report on cardiac services that was carried out by Dr Niall Herity.

“You accept the review?” asked O’Rourke.

“How could you not?” Deasy replied.

Will Harris show the same backbone when it comes to Portlaoise? Or will this plan simply be kicked to touch?

Related Stories

Halligan ‘unwise’ to promise new cath lab, says Cullinane

Harris seeks digital solution to waiting list crisis

Simon Harris: A portrait of the minister as a young man

Health Minister Simon Harris intends 'to give it awful welly'

John Halligan tells FG: ‘sack me if you want’

10 questions about the Portlaoise baby deaths

Susan Mitchell: Health planning is no place to play politics

SBP comment: Patients badly served by government U-turn

Consultants support move to downgrade Portlaoise

Situation critical in Ireland's Emergency Departments

The A&E hitlist: Trauma care to be axed from nine hospitals

Share this post

Related Stories

Private rental sector remains strong despite Covid-19

How the programme for government will shape housing

Insight Niall Byrne 8 months ago

Comment: US must defuse Covid-19’s ticking time bomb of debt

Insight Todd G Buchholz 8 months ago

Comment: The recovery will be more U than V-shaped

Insight Larry Hatheway 8 months ago