Monday February 17, 2020

Off Message: Are novelists no longer allowed to make up stories?

Author Jeanine Cummins, whose brilliant novel American Dirt centres around her Mexican characters’ quest to get into America, has been accused of cultural appropriation. But surely the whole point of fiction is to imagine worlds outside our own experience?

Nadine O’Regan

Arts Editor and Columnist

26th January, 2020
Oprah Winfrey enraged the Culture Police by selecting American Dirt as her Book Club pick

I love a novel that sucks me in completely. When I read, I want to be in a world that overwhelms me. I want to lift off from the grey, rainy days of Dublin, and escape into a character's mindset and life journey. That's what happened to me recently, with Jeanine Cummins’s brilliant new novel American Dirt.

It's the story of a mother and child, who – in the first chapter – lose...

Subscribe from just €1 for the first month!

Exclusive offers:

All Digital Access + eReader



Unlimited Access for 1 Month

Then €19.99 a month after the offer period.

Get basic
*New subscribers only
You can cancel any time.



€149 For the 1st Year

Unlimited Access for 1 Year

You can cancel any time.




90 Day Pass

You can cancel any time.

Team Pass

Get a Business Account for you and your team

Related Stories

With the majority of the US media branded as purveyors of fake news, Fox’s pro-Trump reportage – epitomised by Laura Ingraham – is relentless and unpalatable

Willie O'Reilly | 1 day ago

Ireland’s economic growth model is politically unsustainable with the foreign direct investment regime creating a dynamic of winners and losers

Aidan Regan | 1 day ago

The election results show the new divisions in Ireland are not down party lines but between generations. Young people today face a whole new set of challenges and maybe it’s time we listened to what they have to say

Nadine O’Regan | 1 day ago